An engagement at the end of Bachelor Nation shows isn’t a requirement, but it is an unspoken expectation from viewers. Golden Bachelor lead Mel Owens gave his winner, Peg Munson, his final rose, but not an engagement ring. He presented her with a diamond promise ring instead.
His lack of commitment was a problem in his relationship with his runner-up. Mel Owens opened up after the show about the shocking reason Cindy Cullers turned him off.
Cindy Cullers Quits Golden Bachelor Before Fantasy Suites
Cindy Cullers was ready to leave her home in Austin, Texas, to move to California to pursue a relationship with Mel Owens. She introduced him to her family during the Hometown Dates. But their relationship hit a major bump in Antigua as the Golden Bachelor season was winding down.
Peg Munson was the other finalist for the second season of the popular ABC spinoff. Her connection with Mel was strengthened during their final one-on-one date and Fantasy Suite date. He never made it to the Fantasy Suite with Cindy Cullers.
She made the decision to quit the show before their overnight date. The shocking move came after she confronted him about his feelings for her. She wanted him to profess his love, but he couldn’t.
“I’m just disappointed that you got that far without helping me understand that you weren’t ready for a commitment. Not just me, but all those women that you brought along this journey when did you know that you weren’t ready for something,” Cindy told him during the After the Final Rose special.
Mel Owens reveals his side of why he couldn’t commit to her or Peg with an engagement.
Mel Owens Reveals What Turned Him Off About Cindy
The episode before the season finale ended in a cliffhanger with Cindy pushing Mel to say how he felt about her. When the show picked back up for the season finale, he did speak about how much he enjoyed spending time with her. But that wasn’t enough.
She chose to self-eliminate, leaving Peg Munson as the last woman. Mel and Peg happily left the show together in a relationship, but not engaged. In a joint post-show interview with PEOPLE magazine, he revealed that Cindy turned him off long before she left the show.
“[Cindy] was telling me what I was thinking, and what I did,” he told the outlet. Mel added that she “wanted to be married off the island, and professing her love, death do us part, and off the island with a ring.” He wasn’t interested in that.
Mel Owens denied having commitment issues. “I’m committed, just not to her. My feelings were stronger for Peg, much stronger,” he said about his feelings for his Golden Bachelor winner.
What’s Next For Him & Peg
Cindy Cullers and Mel Owens wished each other the best. Fans hope to see her back as the next Golden Bachelorette. Meanwhile, Peg Owens did her best to shut down rumors of problems in her relationship with the former NFL player already.
Mel Owens told PEOPLE magazine that they plan to take it slow. “We’re going to just do what we do and have fun, and then it’s going to grow from there. Nothing planning about the future of our love story. It’s going to happen naturally,” he said about their relationship.
Peg Munson added, “[It’s] just like when you date somebody. Right? That’s what happens. You just date somebody and then it progresses onto either a proposal or a marriage, or whatever it grows into.”
Tell us in the comments if you think Mel and Peg’s relationship will lead to marriage, or if Cindy was right about his commitment issues.
Jennifer Havener grew up in a small town in Upstate New York. She earned her B.A in Writing & Literature from Naropa University in Boulder, Colorado. She always knew watching reality TV shows and soap operas, particularly ‘Days of Our Lives’, would come in handy someday. When she’s not writing, she’s playing with her dogs, Lola and Ruger
