The Orioles’ decision to tender Ryan Mountcastle an arbitration contract was surprising in November. The already odd fit became all the more so when the O’s signed Pete Alonso to a five-year deal at the Winter Meetings. Mountcastle hasn’t had a real path to playing time since that signing, yet he remains on Baltimore’s roster.
An initial out would have been for the O’s to proceed to an arbitration hearing, then release Mountcastle during Spring Training. Arbitration salaries that are determined at a hearing aren’t fully guaranteed until Opening Day (whether the player wins or loses). Teams can release those players during Spring Training for 30 or 45 days termination pay, depending on when they make that move.
It wouldn’t have been an ideal sequence to drop Mountcastle for a little over $1MM, but that situation isn’t without precedent. The Giants’ decision to release J.D. Davis in Spring Training two years ago was motivated by the Matt Chapman signing, which didn’t take place until after they’d tendered Davis an arbitration contract.
It appears that Mountcastle’s camp learned from the Davis situation. Arbitration hearing salaries aren’t fully guaranteed during the spring, but settlements are locked in at the time of signing. Mountcastle and the Orioles reached a settlement in the middle of January on a $6.787MM deal for 2026, with a $7.5MM club option for the ’27 season. Mountcastle’s ’26 salary is an exact match for what he earned last year.
That’s a savvy move by his representatives, who were clearly aware of the termination pay possibility. Arbitration salaries essentially never decrease year over year, so the $6.787MM number would have been the floor had he gone to a hearing, but it wouldn’t have been locked in until Opening Day. By settling, he ensured that money is fully guaranteed. In exchange, the Orioles picked up the club option that gives them control over a potential free agent year. They did something similar with Ryan O’Hearn a couple seasons ago and were rewarded when O’Hearn played well enough to make an $8MM club option an absolute bargain.
None of that addresses the roster glut, though. It’s frankly difficult to see a path in which Mountcastle is a near-$7MM value to the Orioles in either of the next two years. Alonso basically never takes a day off, so Mountcastle is not going to get first base reps unless the Polar Bear gets injured. They’re likely to divide most of the DH playing time between their two catchers and/or Tyler O’Neill.
Holding Mountcastle as a bench bat isn’t ideal for anyone. It’s a roster spot they’d probably rather use on a utility infielder. They’d be better off clearing the salary and leveraging it into more payroll flexibility at the deadline. The player is entering a potential walk year and should welcome an opportunity to get more at-bats than will be on the table in Baltimore.
That all makes it unsurprising that Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic reported in mid-February that the O’s were still open to trades involving Mountcastle and Coby Mayo. There’s less urgency to trade the latter, who can fill in at third base with Jordan Westburg facing an uncertain timeline due to an elbow ligament injury. Mayo also has a minor league option remaining and could be sent to Triple-A if the infield gets too cluttered. The O’s don’t have that luxury with Mountcastle.
Most of the trade activity is behind us, but we may yet see one or two deals involving notable players before Opening Day. Mountcastle is among the more accomplished players known to be available. He’s coming off a poor season in which he hit .250/.286/.367 while missing two months with a hamstring strain. He was a slightly above-average hitter in each of his first four and a half seasons in the big leagues. Mountcastle has never been a star, but he’s usually reliable for 1-2 wins above replacement. He’s a career .263/.312/.438 hitter in nearly 2700 trips to the plate.
Which teams might still be in touch with O’s president of baseball operations Mike Elias?
Unlock Subscriber-Exclusive Articles Like This One With a Trade Rumors Front Office Subscription
- Access weekly subscriber-only articles by Tim Dierkes, Steve Adams, and Anthony Franco.
- Join exclusive weekly live chats with Anthony.
- Remove ads and support our writers.
- Access GM-caliber tools like our MLB Contract Tracker
