Turns out, the Temptation Island season 2 couples were indeed tempted by the singletons in the villa.
On Temptation Island, a handful of couples agree to live in separate villas with bombshells known as “tempters” and “temptresses,” whose goals are to break up established pairs and find love. At the end of season 2, only Kaylee Needham and Summit Wallace stayed together as the remaining three couples broke up or found a connection with one of the singles.
Keep scrolling to find out which Temptation Island couples are still together after the show — and who broke up:
Kaylee Needham and Summit Wallace
Kaylee and Summit left the Temptation Island villa together, and their romance is still going strong.
“We’re everything I’ve ever wanted to be, [that] is where we are at,” Kaylee revealed the cast’s reunion via the “Viall Files” podcast in April 2026. “It’s amazing. We, like, do everything together, but we’re not so codependent. We also have our own things and we’re independent in our own ways.”
Kaylee further teased that she and Summit plan to move in together and adopt a dog.
“Not yet, but it’s coming,” he quipped of their future living arrangements. “It’s also this idea where I just realized all those things I used to think I wanted to do on my own, I actually do want to do them with Kaylee now.”
As for Kaylee, she feels “way more secure” in her relationship.
“That’s made everything just so much better for us,” she stated. “I can literally look him in the eyes and I know he loves me wholeheartedly without a doubt, and I didn’t feel like that before we went on the show.”
Temptation Island questioned whether established couples could stay together despite obstacles — such as meeting hot single people — but which are still dating and who has broken up? The reality TV show originally debuted on FOX and followed four unmarried couples who traveled to a tropical island to have their fidelity tested. The couples […]
Jack Mason and Shyanne Blankenship
Jack and Shyanne have also remained single since leaving the villa.
“Mutual,” Jack briefly said during the cast’s “Viall Files” reunion.
Cole Mueller and Scarlett Bentley
While Cole and Scarlett agreed to call it quits at the final bonfire, they eventually found their way back to each other.
“We’re together,” she proclaimed on the “Viall Files” podcast.
Sydney McGregor and Mikey Bivens
Sydney left Temptation Island hand-in-hand with bombshell Xzavier Odom, only to reunite with Mikey once production wrapped.
“So, me and Sydney got back together four days after the show,” Mikey said during the reunion. “Everything was going so good and it was going phenomenal, but the thing about it was [that] I was holding on to what I experienced on that island, and that was not fair to her whatsoever, like, any inkling of us having an argument, I’m throwing that jab at her. I saw her as a woman [and] it was tearing her down. I could see her heart was hurt because I’m throwing that at her, and that was not fair.”
Sydney and Mikey’s rekindled relationship only lasted three months.
“Originally when we got back, he was, like, ‘Forget about the show [and] what you did,’ and everything like that,” Sydney said, claiming that Mikey said the bonfire footage of his antics were taken out of context and edited for the dating show. “I felt guilt in myself and I was, like, ‘I don’t want to do that to him.’ He was my best friend.”
Sydney further revealed that she and Mikey have “not talked” in the months since they broke up again, and that she is now “back in communication” with Xzavier.
“I did reach out to him and I was, like, ‘Hey, I know I’m probably the last person you want to talk to, but would you be open to a conversation and grabbing coffee?’” Sydney said. “He was, like,
‘Yes, of course,’ and we went; we got coffee. We talked about everything.”
Sydney, who forged a real connection with Xzavier in the villa, stated that she is now single and “focusing on myself.”
Temptation Island is now streaming on Netflix.
