The Padres will be without Nick Pivetta for quite some time. Manager Craig Stammen told reporters on Wednesday that San Diego’s Opening Day starter has been diagnosed with a flexor strain (link via AJ Cassavell of MLB.com). The righty is being shut down for an indeterminate period.
Stammen said the absence will be measured in “weeks and maybe months.” The manager and pitcher each expressed confidence that Pivetta will be able to return this season. That suggests they’re hopeful he’ll avoid any surgical procedures.
Pivetta was also diagnosed with a flexor strain while a member of the Red Sox in April 2024. That was a mild strain and he recovered quickly, returning to action a month later. This one will seemingly result in a longer absence. Those are the only two non-viral injured list stints of Pivetta’s big league career. Durability has traditionally been a strength.
Matt Waldron will be activated from the injured list on Friday or Saturday to replace Pivetta in the rotation. It’s an alarmingly thin group behind Michael King. Righty Randy Vásquez is now up to #2 on the depth chart, followed by Walker Buehler and Germán Márquez. They’re already without Yu Darvish for the season and have uncertain timelines for Pivetta and Joe Musgrove.
Griffin Canning should be back a couple weeks from now to take one rotation spot. Any of Buehler, Waldron or Márquez could be pushed from the group once Canning is healthy. Waldron made one MLB start last season and had a 6.48 ERA over 21 appearances in Triple-A. Buehler and Márquez were reclamation free agent additions. They’ve each had one good start and two clunkers in the first three turns through the rotation.
Depending on the injury’s severity, this could also have an impact on the upcoming free agent class. Pivetta can opt out of the remaining two years and $32MM on his contract. That’d be an easy call if he’s healthy and pitching anywhere close to last season’s level.
